No, I think the problem is that the program makes the user speak. Of course, it shouldn't do that: If the group is forced to make a decision, it should be a different character making it. In this case, not only is it making the user speak, but it doesn't indicate that this is what happens. All the other problems are minor in comparison.

Has too little information to find what is going on. Also, tends to write about herself as "You"; since it ought to be someone talking to me, using "Me" would seem more appropriate.